Golden Football Magazine
AFL Championship Games
1965: Buffalo Bills @ San Diego Chargers
This series covers the history of the AFL through the prism of its yearly championship games.
Note: The gray boxes contain asides that provide interesting material but could be skipped
without losing the continuity of the article.


Sonny Werblin


Sid Gillman


Lou Saban


Billy Joe


Elbert Dubenion


Glenn Bass


Ernie Wright


Bills captains Tom Sestak and Billy Shaw


Al Bemiller


Joe O'Donnell

At the end of the 1964 season, the American Broadcasting Company decided not to continue its TV coverage of the league after five one-year contracts.
  • ABC instead bid for the NFL contract against both CBS and NBC.
  • CBS won the bid for an astounding $28.2M for two years.
  • The AFL owners pounced on NBC, which had bid triple what the NFL had previ­ously received for its TV coverage. Obviously, the Peacock Network had money to spend.
  • The lead man for the AFL was Jets owner Sonny Werblin, a well-known show business entrepreneur who had been part of ABC's negotiations for the original TV contract with the AFL.
  • The outcome was a $36M deal with NBC over five years. Each of the eight AFL franchises would get $850,000 per year.
  • If the ABC contract had enabled the AFL to survive five years, the NBC money enabled the league to compete better than ever with the NFL in signing top players.
    The TV deal with NBC set in motion a sequence of events that would eventu­ally produce the 1966 merger agreement between the two leagues.
The AFL had repeat champions in both divisions.
  • The Chargers won their third straight West crown and fifth in the six seasons of the upstart league's existence.
  • Think of Sid Gillman's club and offense comes to mind. After all, they led the league in passing offense, rushing offense, and total offense.
  • But they also topped the circuit in passing and rushing defense and therefore total defense (as well as penalties).
  • Hugely disappointed that his team dropped the title game in '64 in Buffalo, Sid vowed to regain the championship in '64.
  • San Diego by no means dominated the division, but their 9-2-3 record put them ahead of the Oakland Raiders two games.

The defending AFL champion Bills amassed the best record in the league, 10-3-1, al­though they feasted on the weaker East Division in which they were the only team over .500. The second place New York Jets, led by rookie QB Joe Namath, the league's most heralded player, finished only 5-8-1 (for the third straight season).

  • Lou Saban had taken most of the season to settle on a running combination after the departure of disgruntled FB Cookie Gilchrist in a trade to Denver in February. It had to come, said Saban. The situation between Cookie and the Bills had become impossible. I felt a change was necessary.
  • The swap brought Billy Joe, the AFL's Rookie of the Year in '63, to take over the FB spot. Joe gained 377y for the Bills, second on the club to Wray Carl­ton's 592.
  • As the season wore on, Saban relegated Joe to a backup spot, moved Carlton to FB, and went with Bob Smith at HB. To show the difference is running backs between the two teams, San Diego's third best RB, rookie Gene Foster, pos­sessed a higher rushing average than anybody the Bills could offer.
  • Buffalo suffered major injuries in the first four games. Knee woes knocked out their top receivers, Elbert Dubenion and Glenn Bass for the season.
    Bass recalled the closeness of the Bills teams of '63-64. We were all concerned about each other. It was a good mixture of blue collar, white collar, black and white. It never was a race issue that I knew of. You hear a lot of coaches and players talk about being family, but it's hard to be family more than two or three years. The egos seem to get in the way. And then people start thinking about their own salary, etc. But it seemed to me in the '64 and '65 championship group, the chemistry was just good.
  • QB Jack Kemp played despite knee and shoulder woes (rumor said the shoul­der was separated) and steered the offense through a maze of personnel adjustments.
  • On the other side of the ball, the Bills finished last in the league in pass de­fense. But the statistic was deceptive because so many passes, 502, were thrown against it. And that was true because of Buffalo's rush defense, which allowed 79.6 ypg, second only to San Diego's 78.1 and 16y fewer per game than the 3rd place Denver Broncos.
    The Bills defense was not afraid of the Chargers' vaunted offense. DB Butch Byrd recalled: We were truly a great defensive team. ... I think anybody will tell you that the strength of the Buffalo Bills team was its defense during those years. ... On paper, I didn't see how we could beat them. They had Lincoln and Lowe and Alworth and Hadl, Kocourek, Ron Mix. ... But on game day, we were just very good, very confident. We just felt that our defense would play with any­body.
  • One area where the Bills could be confident was the kicking game. Veteran Paul Maguire averaged 43.0y per punt whereas the Chargers ranked last in the league (40.0) and would go with a rookie, Jim Allison, who had booted just twice during the season instead of Hadl, who did most of the punting during the season. Also Bills PK Pete Gogolak (28-for-46, 60.9%) held the edge on another Charger rookie, Herb Travenio (18-for-30, 60%).
    Travenio worked part time for the U.S. Postal Service, rising at dawn each morning to sort mail before heading to football practice.

San Diego was favored by 6.5 points on their home field.

  • Saban disregarded the odds makers. For a game like this, you throw away the book and go out and have one heckuva football game.
  • Gillman expected the same. Buffalo is a fine team, and this should be a great football game, unless crazy things happen, as they frequently do. It is going to take everything we own to do the job.
  • The teams met twice in the regular season. The Chargers clobbered the crip­pled Bills in Buffalo October 34-3 in a revenge game for the whipping they en­dured on that same field in the '64 finale. But the Bills kicked a FG in the last minute to gain a 20-20 tie when they visited the coast on Thanksgiving. Buffalo netted only 104y rushing in the two games combined.
  • In the '64 title game, Keith Lincoln started for San Diego but didn't finish after being clobbered by LB Mike Stratton. John Hadl took over at QB in Q4 for the now-retired Tobin Rote. This year, Lincoln's and Hadl's roles would be re­versed. Keith's infirm knee would keep him out of the starting lineup and pos­sibly the entire game. But Hadl would start under C.
  • Fortunately, the Lincoln-less Charger offense still had HB Paul Lowe, who sped for a record 1,121 during the season - only 164y less than the entire Buffalo team had compiled.
  • Unlike Rote the year before, Hadl didn't have to worry about a sore arm. I haven't had a sore arm since my senior year in college, and that's a curious thing. We didn't throw the ball enough at Kansas to worry about our arms.
  • Purists said that Hadl lacked style. But the statistics said he was the #1 QB in the league, although writers conferred that distinction on his opposite number, Jack Kemp of the Bills.
  • OT Ernie Wright had been bothered by a sprained ankle and would be replaced in the starting lineup by Gary Kirner. The Chargers would miss Wright badly.
  • Gillman was so confident that he predicted a blowout and told columnist Larry Felser of the Buffalo Evening News before the game, You know, there is no way we can lose this game. When asked why, Sid explained, Because of Jack Kemp. We're going to win this game because Kemp has the maturity of a 10-year-old girl.
    According to Felser, Gillman made his boast after he had been drinking.
    The teams had met a month before, and Keith Lincoln barely played. He had a beef with Sid. It was probably over money. ... I knew Lincoln and talked to him after that game. As we finished, I said, "You'd always be welcomed in Buffalo." He said, "I'd love to play in Buffalo." So I wrote it.
    The Friday night before the game, there was a party at a Hilton in a private little dining room. I was talking to Esther Gillman, who was a Hall of Fame wife. All of a sudden, I heard a guy hissing in my ear, and he said, "You are no longer welcome in the San Diego Chargers' dressing room." I turned around, and it was Sid. He was going on about the Lincoln story. Well, it was a party. Everybody had been drinking. I got up and told Sid, "You may tell the San Diego press what to write about, but you'll never tell me what to write about." ... By that time, Sid was trying to calm me down: "Larry! Larry! Let me buy you a drink!" We went up to the bar. He bought a round. I bought a round. After a while, he was telling me, "There's no way we can lose this game. Jack Kemp has the maturity of a 10-year-old girl." He went on and on. A couple of friends helped me to my room. I woke up at 6:00 A.M. the next day with the mother of all hangovers when I got a call from Sid: "Larry, about that conversation we had last night ..." To which I replied, "What conversation?" Then he said, "Go back to sleep." Click.

Saban took his squad from Buffalo to the West Coast for a week of workouts in California winter weather.

  • Lou's game plan was simple: control the ball and keep SD's dynamic offense off the field. To that end, he wanted more bootlegs and play action passes.
  • To that end, he planned to start two TEs: veteran Ernie Warlick, who had warmed the bench for nine weeks, and Paul Costa, who had an exceptional rookie year: 21 catches for 401y, a performance that earned him a Pro Bowl spot.
  • Also, Carlton, a 230-pounder, would switch to FB where he could afford Kemp extra protection when passing while Joe would take the HB spot.
    Carlton: We were more of a solid football team. We just didn't have any weak­nesses. We weren't glamorous or anything. ... we were a ball-control offense. ... We were a strong special teams. Paul Maguire was a great punter. ... Most of our guys were just blue-collar guys that just went out and beat you. Just very methodical, mistake-free football. Ball-control, solid defense, great special teams, a good field-goal kicker with Gogolak.
  • Saban believed in a cohesive, veteran O-line. However, a back injury to C Dave Behrman forced him to move Al Bemiller from RG to C, a position he hadn't played in two years. Al would have to contend with 315-lb DT Ernie Ladd, who would enjoy a 55 lb advantage over the new C. Second-year pro Joe O'Donnell would fill in at RG.
  • On the other side of the ball, the Bills decided to double-team Lance Alworth on every play, the first time Joe Collier's defense had ever done that for any opponent.
    Costa recalled: In San Diego, we were out every night, drinking beer, having a good time. Not staying out late. We were going to the same places as the San Diego players. And they were giving us the business: "We're gonna kill you guys. We're gonna mop you up." But it was friendly stuff. And that whole week, we took it from them.
    Butch Byrd: The night before the game, Paul Maguire and severa other Bills were out at a party, and Don Norton, one of the Chargers' receivers, told Paul what he was going to do to me the next day. I was incensed. Norton never had a good day against me. And Paul told Joe Collier, the DB coach at the time. Before the game, Joe called me in for a special one-on-one and said, "I don't want you to get too excited out there. I want you to play your game." I said words to the effect of: "Not a thing to worry about."

NBC, culminating the first year of its AFL contract, televised the game coast-to-coast to an expected audience of 40 million.

  • The TV announcers were Curt Gowdy, Paul Christman, and Charlie Jones.
  • Herb Carneal and George Ratterman handled the NBC radio broadcast.
1965 Buffalo Bills
# Player Pos. Hgt. Wgt. College Exp.
3 Pete Gogolak K 6-1 190 Cornell 2
12 Daryle Lamonica QB 6-3 215 Notre Dame 3
15 Jack Kemp QB 6-0 200 Occidental 9
20 Bobby Smith HB 6-0 205 North Texas 2
22 Charley Warner DB 6-0 175 Prairie View 3
24 Booker Edgerson CB 5-10 185 Western Illinois 4
26 George Saimes S 5-11 185 Michigan State 3
27 Tom Janik DB 6-3 190 Texas A&M/A&M K'ville 3
30 Wray Carlton FB 6-2 225 Duke 6
32 Donnie Stone FB 6-1 205 Arkansas 5
33 Billy Joe HB 6-2 235 Villanova 3
40 Ed Rutkowski KR 6-1 200 Notre Dame 3
42 Butch Byrd CB 6-0 210 Boston University 2
45 Hagood Clarke DB 6-0 205 Florida 2
46 Bo Roberson FL 6-1 190 Cornell 5
48 Pete Mills FL 5-10 180 Wichita State 1
50 Al Bemiller G-C 6-3 245 Syracuse 5
51 John Tracey LB 6-3 225 Texas A&M 7
52 Bill Laskey LB 6-3 235 Michigan 1
55 Paul Maguire P 6-0 230 The Citadel 6
56 Marty Schottenheimer LB 6-3 225 Pittsburgh 1
58 Mike Stratton LB 6-3 225 Tennessee 4
60 Dave Behrman C 6-5 260 Michigan State 3
64 Harry Jacobs LB 6-1 225 Bradley 6
66 Billy Shaw G 6-2 260 Georgia Tech 5
67 Joe O'Donnell G-T 6-2 250 Michigan 2
70 Tom Sestak DT 6-5 265 Baylor, McNeese State 4
72 Ron McDole DE 6-4 265 Nebraska 5
73 George Flint G 6-4 240 Arizona State 4
75 Dudley Meredith DT 6-4 280 Florida, Lamar 3
76 Henry Schmidt DT 6-4 255 USC, Trinity (TX) 7
77 Stew Barber T 6-2 250 Penn State 5
78 Jim Dunaway DT 6-4 275 Mississippi 3
79 Dick Hudson T 6-3 275 Memphis State 4
80 Charley Ferguson E 6-5 215 Tennessee State 4
82 Paul Costa TE 6-5 255 Notre Dame 1
84 Ernie Warlick TE 6-3 235 North Carolina Central 4
88 Tom Day DE 6-2 250 North Carolina A&T 6
1965 San Diego Chargers
# Player Pos. Hgt. Wgt. College Exp.
15 Don Breaux QB 6-1 205 McNeese State 3
19 Lance Alworth WR 6-0 185 Arkansas 4
20 Miller Farr DB 6-1 190 Wichita State 1
21 John Hadl QB 6-1 215 Kansas 4
22 Keith Lincoln FB 6-1 215 Washington State 5
23 Paul Lowe HB 6-0 205 Oregon State 6
25 Dick Westmoreland DB 6-1 190 North Carolina A&T 3
30 Bob Horton LB 6-2 230 Boston University 2
32 Jim Allison FB-P 6-0 215 San Diego State 1
33 Kenny Graham S 6-0 200 Washington State 2
34 Bob Zeman DB 6-1 200 Wisconsin 6
35 Herb Travenio K 6-0 220 None 2
36 Dick Harris DB 5-11 185 McNeese State 6
37 Gene Foster FB 6-0 220 Arizona State 1
38 Jacque MacKinnon E 6-4 235 Colgate 5
45 Speedy Duncan DB 5-10 180 Jackson State 2
47 Bud Whitehead S 5-11 185 Florida State 5
49 Jimmy Warren CB 5-11 185 Illinois 2
50 Chuck Allen MLB 6-0 225 Washington 5
51 Dick Degen LB 6-1 225 Long Beach State 1
55 Frank Buncom MLB 6-1 240 USC 4
56 Steve DeLong DE 6-2 250 Tennessee 1
60 Ed Mitchell DT 6-2 285 Nebraska, Southern 1
61 Ernie Park G 6-3 255 McMurry 3
62 John Farris G 6-4 245 San Diego State 1
65 Sam Gruneisen C-G 6-1 240 Villanova 4
71 Fred Moore DT 6-3 255 Oklahoma, Mem. St. 2
72 Gary Kirner G-T 6-3 255 USC 2
74 Ron Mix T 6-4 250 USC 6
75 Ernie Wright T 6-4 270 Ohio State 6
77 Ernie Ladd DT 6-9 300 Grambling State 5
78 Walt Sweeney G 6-4 255 Syracuse 3
79 George Gross DT 6-3 260 Auburn 3
83 Dave Kocourek TE 6-5 240 Wisconsin 6
85 Bob Petrich DE 6-4 250 West Texas State 3
86 Earl Faison DE 6-5 270 Indiana 5
87 Howard Kindig DE-T 6-6 265 Los Angeles State 1
88 Don Norton E 6-1 190 Iowa 6
89 Ron Carpenter LB 6-2 230 Texas A&M 2


Herb Travenio


George Flint


Jack Kemp and Wray Carlton


Ernie Warlick


Bo Roberson


Jimmy Warren


Bills' Front Four (L-R): Tom Day, Tom Sestak, Jim Dunaway, Ron McDole


Bills' Secondary (L-R): Butch Byrd, George Saimes, Hagood Clarke, Booker Edgerson


Lance Alworth


Lowe muffs a pass.


Jim Allison


Paul Costa


Paul Maguire


Don Norton


Gene Foster


Mike Stratton


Speedy Duncan


Hadl enveloped by Bills.



Bob Petrich


John Tracey


Don Breaux


Bills victory banquet.

Rain fell the day before the game. Gillman hired helicopters to dry out the field and maximize his club's speed advantage.

Buzz Ponce worked as a ballboy for the Chargers in 1965. His assignment was to assist the visiting team. Here is his 2013 recollection of the '65 championship game day.

So there I was at 8 a.m. ... in the Bills' locker room unpacking boxes and sorting through equipment, getting uniforms and gear ready for the 1 p.m. kick-off. I remember Buffalo's loquacious equipment manager Tony Marchitte barking orders, taking charge of his min­ions and turning the dungeon that was Balboa's locker room into an organized, efficient space.
As the players began to arrive, the mood within that dungeon became palpable. It was a quiet, somber resolve. There seemed to be a steadfastness — a commitment — that perme­ated the locker room area and seeped into the soul of the Buffalo Bills. I had several chances that morning to duck quickly into San Diego's side of the stadium and noticed a decidedly different ambiance. The Chargers players were smiling, joking and seemingly looking forward to the beer and champagne that was already tucked away, ready for the celebration that was sure to come San Diego's way. ...

A crowd of 30,361 at Balboa Stadium enjoyed a temperature of 59° and slight wind.

  • Quarter 1
    Herb Travenio kicked off to Charlie Warner, who returned from the goal line to the 17. Bills G Billy Shaw, the offensive captain, was knocked silly and left the field for the first half. George Flint took his place.
    The Bills immediately implemented their plan of running the ball to control the clock. Billy Joe gained 5, Wray Carlton 4, then, with Ernie Warlick in as a second TE, Carlton pushed for the first down at the 27. Then Jack Kemp threw his first pass of the day. Bo Roberson snagged it and ran clear across the field before going out of bounds on the 39 to move the chains again. But after Carlton gained 3, the drive ended when CB Jimmy Warren stepped in front of Kemp's pass at the SD 33.

    Kemp throws pass just before Ernie Ladd arrives.
    The Chargers moved into Buffalo territory when John Hadl threw a 2nd-and-10 pass to Lance Alworth on a hook pattern to the 47. But two runs gained only 1, and Hadl had to dump the ball under pressure to his safety valve, Paul Lowe, for no gain. Rookie punter Jim Allison kicked off the side of his foot just 19y to the 27.
    On 2nd down, Kemp hit TE Paul Costa to the 38. On 3rd-and-2, Jack made a great fake to Carlton but lobbed the ball too high over the middle to Costa. So Paul Maguire banged a punt to the 9.
    Lowe immediately got the Chargers out of the hole with a brilliant 47y run to the Buffalo 44. But the Bills defense sacked Hadl two straight plays for a total loss of 11, DT Tom Sestak diving and tripping him on the second one. After an overthrown pass to Alworth, Allison tried his foot at punting again but did even worse - just 9y to the 46. Bob would kick no more on the afternoon, Hadl resuming that duty the rest of the game.
    But the Bills couldn't take advantage of the excellent field position. Following Carlton's 4y run, Ernie Ladd, playing head up over backup C Al Bemiller, burst through so quickly that Kemp had to throw away a screen pass. After another incompletion, Maguire sailed a punt to the 11.
    Backed up for the second straight possession, San Diego tried the same play on which Lowe gained 47 earlier but it went nowhere. The Bills chose to decline a holding penalty, which would have been only 6y instead of 15. But the decision backfired when Lowe turned the left corner to the 21 and a first down. On 2nd down, Hadl connected with Don Norton streaking over the middle for 33y to the Bills 44. The visitors had to consider the opening period a victory since they held the potent Chargers offense scoreless.
    END Q1: CHARGERS 0 BILLS 0

    Paul Lowe takes a handoff from John Hadl as Gary Kirner (72) gives chase.
  • Quarter 2
    Rookie HB Gene Foster darted through a gaping hole up the middle to within a foot of the 1st down at the 34. Lowe then pushed over RT to the 33. 1st-and-10. CB Booker Edgerson got physical with Alworth as Bambi tried to get loose, causing him to trip. So Hadl ran out of bounds for a loss of 2. Again finding no one open, John used his feet to the 28. On 3rd-and-5, his pass to Lowe down the middle misfired as George Saimes banged Lowe, who couldn't hang on. So Travenio came in for a FG attempt. Sestak and LB Mike Stratton got a good push and one of them deflected the ball, which rolled to the 5.
    On 2nd-and-7, Kemp got some breathing space by connecting with Warlick to the 20. But that's as far as the Bills got. Three incompletions brought in Maguire, who got off another tremendous boot to Speedy Duncan, who took the ball over his shoulder at the 25 and returned 8y. Buffalo's special teams were soundly out­playing their counterparts.
    On 2nd-and-8, the Chargers were guilty of holding. The 15y markup put the pig­skin on the 14. Then another fine play by Sestak moved the ball back even further. As Lowe came around on a reverse, Tom rose from being blocked and tripped up Paul at the 8. So Hadl dropped back to punt. As if to say, "Coach, you should have had me punting me from the beginning," John boomed a 62-yarder to Butch Byrd, who returned to the his 40.
    Continuing to run straight at the defense with a pass mixed in here and there, the Bills moved to the day's first score. Two Carlton runs moved the chains to the Chargers 44. Kemp then rolled right and lobbed a pass to Costa. The big, agile TE took it over his shoulder and stepped out of bounds at the 22. After two runs gained 4, Jack found the other TE, Warlick, under the goal posts. Gogolak con­verted. Buffalo 7 San Diego 0 (4:59)
    Afterward, Warlick explained the TD play. I just fake out, then head for the goal posts. It worked fine. I suspect Duncan wasn't accustomed to my move because we hadn't played with two TEs before.

    Jack Kemp throws TD pass to Warlick.
    Rookie Miller Farr got a good return from the EZ to the 30. Keith Lincoln, with his bad knee, entered the game at FB for the first time. Under constant pressure, Hadl almost threw an INT on 1st down before connecting on 2nd down with Alworth, who made a diving catch at the 45 for a 1st down. Lincoln gained 3 on a draw play before George Saimes came around the edge on a S blitz and, with MLB Harry Jacobs, sacked Hadl at the 34. A futile pass forced Hadl to punt. He got off ano­ther good kick, but the high spiral turned into a disaster when Byrd took the ball at his 26, delayed a second as if expecting to be tackled, then burst past the first wave of coverage, and ran down the right sideline past the Chargers bench to pay dirt, pausing only to let a blocker take out the last defender, Hadl. The 74y return set an AFL championship game record. Buffalo 14 San Diego 0 (2:29)
    Byrd: Right after I caught the ball, our blocks cleared out everybody near me. So I headed up the sideline. MacKinnon got a hand on me, but I managed to break loose. Maguire hit Hadl. Then I was worried I might run out of bounds. I was real sur­prised when I didn't see any blue jerseys as I headed down the sideline.
    Chargers DB Kenny Graham, who was on the bench at the time: He stepped on the line. The official should have whistled the play dead. I had a strong impulse to trip Byrd, but I didn't do it.

    Butch Byrd starts on his record-setting punt return as Hagood Clarke takes out Dick Harris.
    Hadl's frustration continued when Jacobs picked off his 1st down pass at the 32 and returned 12y.
    Following the two-minute warning, the Bills tried to move in for a three-score lead. But three plays gained only 3y. So Gogolak came out for a 24y FG from the right hash mark, but Duncan got a hand on the ball, and it rolled harmlessly into the EZ.
    With all three timeouts left and 1:25 on the clock, the Chargers hoped to get on the board before halftime. On 3rd-and-5, Hadl connected with Alworth on the run to the 47. Following the second timeout at the 1:03 mark, Hadl ran out of the pocket to the Buffalo 40, then used SD's final timeout. After three short comple­tions to the boundary put the pigskin on the 26, Hadl inexplicably handed off to Lincoln, who gained 2 as the clock ticked under 10 seconds. The FG unit hurried out, but Travenio's kick sailed wide left. HALFTIME: BUFFALO 14 SAN DIEGO 0
    Stratton: We went to the locker room at halftime and were looking at each other saying, "Hadl, he doesn't have a clue." He didn't know whether to call timeouts or wind his watch. We changed some looks and things. We could do anything we wanted to.
    Ballboy Buzz Ponce reminisced years later: On the visitors sideline during the game, I remember Saban always looking calm, confident and in control. For a kid who loved the Chargers, I couldn't help it - I was impressed with the coach and his team. The Bills and their low-key self assurance that day contrasted sharply to San Die­go's attitude and even though the first half ended with just a 7-0 score in favor of Buffalo [actually 14-0], I dejectedly sensed it was lights out for the Chargers.

    At halftime, Commissioner Joe Foss presents AFL Player of the Year
    Paul Lowe the keys to a new car.
  • Quarter 3
    If Charger fans expected their idols to show a rejuvenated offense after receiving the kickoff, they were sadly disappointed. Three plays netted nothing. But they did see Hadl continue his excellent punting - 57y to Byrd, who was smothered for a -2y return at his 27.
    Continuing to do a better imitation of the SD offense than Hadl & Company, the Bills started strong. Kemp threw long down the right sideline to Roberson, who took the ball in stride over his shoulder just beyond CB Jimmy Warren and step­ped out at the 24. Two runs by Carlton and a quick pass to Warlick moved the chains to the 12. But three more runs fell 1y short of another first down. So Go­golak kicked an 11y FG. Buffalo 17 San Diego 0 (9:21)

    Gogolak boots the first his three FGs for the day.
    Duncan gave the Chargers a spark when he returned the kickoff 49y to the Buf­falo 48. Lincoln then took a handoff and gained 10. But after Lowe gained 3, Hadl recovered a fumble on a misfired handoff. Then, back to pass, John ran to the 28. Needing a half-yard for the 1st, the backfield had another mixup as Hadl turned but found no one there for the handoff and was dropped for a 2y loss.
    A holding penalty on 2nd down set the Bills back all the way to the 11. No prob­lem. Kemp threw deep again to Roberson, who gathered in the pigskin at the 40 and ran 8 more yards. Three straight Joe carries failed to produce another 1st down. So Maguire punted, dropping a 9 iron inside the 10 that Warner downed at the 1.
    Going for broke, Hadl threw long from the EZ on the first play, but Byrd intercepted at the 45 and returned to the 23.
    Byrd: I was so focused on Norton. Hadl threw a sideline ball over his head, and I just blasted him as hard as I could. Those were the days that, when the ball was in the air, you could hit the wide receiver. He looked at me. His eyes were huge. We were running down the sidelines later, right in front of Sid Gillman. Hadl still had the ball, and I blasted Norton again, knocked him right into Gillman. I jumped up and looked at Gillman and said, "You'd better get him out of this game or I'm going to kill him!" Gillman looked at me like I was crazy.
    DE Bob Petrich chased Kemp out of the pocket and downed him at the 32. Jack fumbled on the play and a Charger fell on it, but the officials ruled the whistle had blown. That set off a chorus of boos from the frustrated crowd that delayed the game momentarily. When play resumed, two incompletions set up Gogolak for a 39y FG that he sent through the uprights. Buffalo 20 San Diego 0 (0:45)

    Gogolak boots another FG.
    The SD line continued to have trouble holding off the Bills push. Stepping back from DE Ron McDole's pressure, Hadl threw short over the middle. Then he had to run again, gaining 8.
    END Q3: BUFFALO 20 SAN DIEGO 0

    Byrd can't get away from Kenny Graham.
  • Quarter 4
    San Diego's offensive ineptitude continued as they started from the 20. First, premature motion drew Buffalo offside as Lincoln gained only 1 of the 2 needed for a 1st down. When the Bills declined the penalty, Gillman gave the word to go for it. Lowe started wide left and, with blockers in front of him, appeared to have a chance to make the 1st down. But he slipped as he cut in to fall 1/2y short.
    Already in FG range from the 30, the Bills started with a hard-driving 11y run from Joe. But on 2nd-and-11, Kemp slipped and fell when trying to pass for a loss of 6. A short run put the ball on the 25. From there, Gogolak booted his third FG of the afternoon, a 32-yarder. Buffalo 23 San Diego 0 (11:45)

    Kemp hands to Joe.
    Hadl started with a short pass over the middle to Lincoln for 7y to the 27. But both outside LBs blitzed on the next snap and snowed Hadl under. DT Jim Duna­way completed the outstanding series for the Bills D by batting down Hadl's pass.
    Buffalo stayed on the ground and, aided by a face mask penalty, reached the SD 40. Gogolak lined up a 46y FG, but Daryle Lamonica took the snap and threw to LB John Tracey for a 1st down on the 28.

    Daryle Lamonica rolls out on the fake FG play.
    One play later, Lamonica came back in for Kemp, who received a nice round of applause as he left the field.
    As Jack came to the sideline, a fan yelled, Kemp, we want you back. Please come back! Jack had played the 1961 season and half the '62 campaign for the Char­gers before being traded to Buffalo. Gillman reportedly said, We can't win with Kemp.
    On 4th-and-6 from the 25, the Hungarian-born kicker tried for a new championship game record, but the ball sailed wide left with 3:40 on the clock.
    The only suspense remaining was whether the Chargers could avoid a shutout. Hadl hit Alworth for a 25y pass and run to the 45. Hit as he threw the ball, John left as did Lance. Don Breaux took over at QB. On his second snap, Don connect­ed with Farr, who made a leaping catch at the Buffalo 36. But Saimes rushed through on a S blitz to nail Breaux for a loss of 12. Two more sacks continued the humiliation, and Hadl came in to punt into the EZ.
    As the Chargers huddled on their last series, LB Tracey did the twist to celebrate the victory. Come out, and we'll show you some defense, he taunted.
    The Bills ran twice to mercifully end the lopsided contest.
    FINAL SCORE: BILLS 23 CHARGERS 0
Jack Kemp took home the championship game MVP to sit on a shelf beside the same award that the media had bestowed on him for the regular season.

Final statistics:

  • First downs: Bills 23 Chargers 12
  • Rushing: Bills 36-108 Chargers 27-104
  • Passing: Bills 20-9-1/152 Chargers 25-12-2/119
  • Return yardage: Bills 6-138 Chargers 5-109
  • Fumbles-Lost: Bills 1-0 Chargers 1-0
  • Penalties: Bills 2-21 Chargers 3-41
  • Punting average: Bills 4-46.3 Chargers 7-40.7

Each victorious Bill received $5,189 while the Chargers pocketed $3,447 apiece.

Postgame

Buffalo Locker Room

  • For the second year in a row, the Bills gave the game ball to the coaching staff. The team that was so solemn before the game now let loose with beer and champagne aplenty.
  • Saban: This was the only club we didn't beat this year, and we wanted this one. We whipped them in the trenches where we knew we would have to do it. We didn't use much new stuff and double covered their receivers by rotation. Our pass rushing was great. ... I figure we also got good games out of (offensive) linemen Al Bemiller, Joe O'Donnell, and George Flint. Lou agreed that Byrd's punt return was a key play. That was the play of the day, that and Kemp's TD pass to Warlick. Kemp and Warlick got us in front 7-0, and I figured the first team that scored would be the winner. It was that kind of game. I knew it was going to be tough.
  • Californian Kemp: Oh God, I can't believe it - right here in San Diego too. A teammate yelled, Pour it on 'em, Jack. But the grinning future politician resisted the temptation to reply directly to Gillman's derogatory comment about him before the game. Instead, he said, No, I'm not going to say anything. ... We won by clawing and digging, the way we've won all year. Nobody expects to shut out the Chargers. I'm glad it came today. We had to do it. We had to prove we're really the champs. Last year, they said we were lucky because Lincoln and Alworth were out of the game. I don't believe we had the best manpower, but we had the best football team. ... We just wanted to roll out more and do somethings like bootlegs and play action passes.
  • Maguire, another former Charger, rubbed it in. I hope Sid Gillman cuts some more of us. We can use them. Boy, I loved every minute of it. Paul poured champagne over anyone within reach, including sportscaster Charlie Jones doing interviews in his bright NBC coat and tie.
    Decades later, Kemp recalled the back-to-back championships: In '64, we were successful because we had an all-around team. We had offense with Cookie (Gilchrist) and my passing. Good running and good blocking. And we had the greatest defense in the AFL ... The next year, Cookie was gone. We didn't quite have the offensive weapons, but we had a great defense. And we beat the heck out of the Chargers! They were so overconfident. I think they were two-touch­down favorites [actually one], and we whipped them convincingly.
  • Ex-Charger Bo Roberson: You can see the Charger alumni came home to haunt Sid. I have had better days as a pro, but my catches were vital ones today.
  • D-coordinator Joe Collier was not surprised his unit had played so well. The defense was so high all week I was talking to their kneecaps. He explained the strategy. We double-teamed Al­worth on almost every play. When he lined up at flanker, Booker Edgerson and Hagood Clarke double-covered him. When he was at split-end, it was George Saimes and Booker.
  • Tom Sestak: We had tremendous unity because we wanted this one, naturally, more than any other game this year. Our pass rush worked better today because we had a dry field. It seems we had been on a wet field the last six weeks.
  • Byrd was assigned to cover E Don Norton. We had words going during the game, but I don't want to talk about it. I did think I did a pretty good job on Norton, and that punt return of mine was one of the key plays of the game.
    Years later, Ron McDole explained the Bills' success this way: We were following Lou Saban. He kept saying we could win. We just had a lot of good ballplayers. We didn't have that one per­son. ... It seemed like every week, somebody else would step up and get the job done one way or another. ... In fact, the '64 and '65 championship teams, there weren't that many different ball­players on those teams. I think that was the big success. We just played well together, and the coaching was good ...
San Diego Locker Room
  • The Chargers were shocked and dismayed. Gillman kept newsmen out of the dressing room for a few minutes before facing the music. We just got beat. We lost to a fine football team. The Bills have excellent personnel and coaching. What else is there to say?
  • Hadl: I don't know what happened. I really don't. We were outplayed. They kicked the devil out of us. We keep trying - what else can you do?
  • DBs Warren and Graham disagreed on the game. They overpowered us, said Warren. No, they didn't, Jimmy, countered Graham. I don't think we were as hungry as we should have been. On any given day, we've got a better team. I don't think we were fatheaded. We carried out our assignments. The difference was that the Bills carried out their assignments, then went out and did something else. That's when you win football game.
  • Overhearing the conversation, LB Bob Horton put in his two cents worth. I don't want to sound mystical, but there are times when you walk on the field and you just don't get the job done. It was that kind of day. Those guys are huge. Warren added, People don't know how strong they really are.
  • Alworth summed up the game as well as anybody. We didn't play the way we're capable of playing for some reason. They really got ready; they were fired up. We thought we were, but evidently we weren't. It was just like the rest of the day, my getting hurt near the end. It feels like I have a broken rib. We couldn't get anything going, and they played like champs.
  • Norton: It was a frustrating day. I don't understand it, really. It was an amazing thing.
A week later, Saban stunned Buffalo Nation by resigning and taking the head coaching position at the University of Maryland.
1965 AFL Champion Buffalo Bills

References: The Little League That Could: A History of the American Football League, Ken Rappoport (2010)
The Other League: The Fabulous Story of the American Football League, Jack Horrigan and Mike Rathet (1970)
Then Levy Said to Kelly...: The Best Buffalo Bills Stories Ever Told, Jim Gehman (2008)
Going Long: The Wild 10-Year Saga of the Renegade American Football League
in the Words of Those Who Lived It:
Jeff Miller (2003)
"1965 AFL Title Game: Was it the San Diego Chargers' Own 'Curse of the Bambino'?", Buzz Ponce, bleacherreport.com 6/24/13
Top of Page