Golden Football Magazine
AFL Championship Games
1964: San Diego Chargers @ Buffalo Bills
This series covers the history of the AFL through the prism of its yearly championship games.
Note: The gray boxes contain asides that provide interesting material but could be skipped
without losing the continuity of the article.

John Hadl


Ernie Ladd


Lou Saban


Glenn Bass


Elbert Dubenion


Pete Gogalak


Billy Shaw


Jerry Robinson


Daryle Lamonica

The San Diego Chargers defended their AFL West Conference championship but just barely.
  • After winning six in a row to run their record to 7-2-1, they lost three of their last four to limp home 8-5-1. That was still good enough to top the Kansas City Chiefs by 1.5 games.
  • San Diego's roughly 2-to-1 passing-to-rushing ratio reflected the league's over­all imbalance.
  • The key to the offense was WR Lance Alworth, who led the league with 13 TD receptions and ranked near the top with 20.2y per catch.
  • Throwing to Alworth were two QBs, John Hadl, who started eight games, and Tobin Rote, who started the other six. Hadl's completion % of 53.6 was second highest in the AFL.
  • FB Keith Lincoln and HB Paul Lowe combined for 1128y on the ground.
  • Three Chargers made the AFL All-Star team: T Ron Mix, DE Earl Faison, and DT Ernie Ladd.

The East produced the five-year league's two best teams, record-wise.

  • The 12-2 Buffalo Bills and 10-3-1 Boston Patriots were the only two double-di­git winners in the eight-team circuit.
  • Lou Saban's Bills didn't clinch the spot in the AFL Championship Game until the last day of the regular season when they defeated the defending East champion Patriots 24-14 at Fenway Park. The victory avenged a home loss November 15, 36-28, as well as the defeat in the East Division playoff game in 1963.
    A LB and captain on Paul Brown's Cleveland team of the AAFC, Saban had been head coach of the Boston Patriots when the AFL started in 1960. He joined the Bills two years later. Jack Kemp recalled, He was one of the great coaches from the early days of the American Football League, along with Sid Gill­man, Al Davis, and Hank Stram. Bills receiver Ed Rutkowski: Saban new how to press that button in all of us and how to get the best out of us. I remember when we had our first two wide receivers go down ... I had to go in with Glenn Bass. I think the first game I was going to start ... was against the Jets. So I stayed after practice to work on my pass routes and everything else. The Thursday before the game, ... I'm walking off the field after practice, and coach comes over to me and says, "You know, Ed, whether we win or not depends on your perform­ance." I said, "What do you mean?" "Well, this game rests on you. You better have a hell of a game, otherwise we're going to lose." Well, I was all fired up. I had one of the best games of my life. And I found out years later at one of our reunions that he said the exact same thing to Glenn Bass. Booker Edgerson on Saban: He was a good man. You could believe him. ... he treated everybody the same. He was a great motivator. He could give you a pep talk. He used to tell me, "If you don't catch the ball, I'm going to cut you." That was motivation enough for me.
  • Buffalo featured the only defense in the league to yield less than 1,000y for the season. On the other side of the ball, 250-lb FB Cookie Gilchrist accounted for 981y on the ground, more than the 913y total the Bills gave up on 300 carries - an AFL record. Needless to say, Buffalo led the league in rushing yards (2,040).
    Gilchrist had been placed on waivers in early November after clashing with head coach Saban. The Bills had reeled off nine victories without a defeat with Cookie in the lineup, but, with owner Ralph Wilson's consent, it was agreed that Gilchrist be placed on waivers. The big FB, however, contacted QB Jack Kemp and pleaded for another chance. Kemp heard Cookie out and believed he was really sorry. Jack in turn contracted key leaders on the team, who agreed that Gilchrist could return if he would apologize to the team for the in­cident and guarantee that he would play his heart out. After a two-hour meet­ing, Saban relented.
  • QB play was not the Bills' strong suit. Jack Kemp completed only 44.2% of his passes with 13 TDs and twice that many INTs. No one receiver stood out with WR Glenn Bass leading the club with 43 receptions but Elbert Dubenion gaining the most yards, 1139, on 42 catches. Gilchrist was third, adding 345 to his rush­ing yardage on 30 passes.
    After being Buffalo's Offensive Most Valuable Player in 1961, Bass was re­leased by Saban after the Bills opened the 1963 campaign with back-to-back losses. Glenn drove 16 hours to his home in Wilson NC only to return to Buffa­lo the next day. I just disagreed with his assessment. I drove back and went to his home and told him that I didn't feel like I'd been treated fairly and didn't agree with his decision and that I would be on the taxi squad and prove my worth. So I was a halfback on the taxi squad for a couple weeks, and then I was placed back on the roster.
  • The Bills employed rookie Pete Gogolak, who booted 19 of 28 FGs, including one that beat the Chargers 27-24 in San Diego Thanksgiving Day to complete the home-and-home sweep. By contrast, San Diego's K, George Blair, had been hurt most of the season. Lincoln, a fine FB, took over the chore but made only 5 of 12 FG attempts.
    Born in Hungary, Pete Gogolak came to the U.S. when his family escaped the Communist regime there. He brought with him his love of soccer. The football coach at his high school in upstate New York recruited him to kick for him and didn't insist that he change his "sidewinder" soccer approach, booting the ball with his instep instead of his toe. He set records at Cornell University before signing with the Bills. He thus brought another innovation to the AFL that spread throughout all levels of football.
    Gogolak: They took a chance on me, in the 12th round. Back then there were no specialists at all. Nobody from the NFL touched me. So I went up to Buffalo ... Jack Kemp was the QB. Jack never wanted to hold for me because he said somebody once kicked his finger. I basically made the team because I kicked a 57-yard FG in the first exhibition game ... I think (owner) Ralph Wilson said, "We're going to keep this guy. He might bring some people to the stadium."
  • The All-Star team included six Bills: Gilchrist, G Billy Shaw, T Stew Barber, DT Tom Sestak, LB Mike Stratton, and S George Saimes.
    A second round pick from Georgia Tech in 1961, Shaw moved directly into the starting lineup at LG and became the anchor of an outstanding line. He is the only member of the Pro Football Hall of Fame who played his entire career in the NFL. Shaw on Coach Saban: Lou was always looking for perfection, and he just had a vision from his viewpoint on the sidelines. And Lou was a very, very intelligent person, and he could see things on the field.
In the weeks before the AFL and NFL championship games, the National Academy of Sports put this question to its members: "Does the NFL have an obligation (to the public) to accept the AFL's invitation for an all-pro championship game?" The sports editors voted 51% in favor, 42% opposed, and 7% indifferent. The results were more interesting when broken down by city. The sports editors in AFL cities favored the mo­tion 69%-31%. Editors from NFL cities also voted in the affirmative but by a smaller margin: 52% to 37% with 7% indifferent. In non-league cities, the vote was negative: 48% no, 45% yes, 7% indifferent.

The Chargers received a piece of coal in their Christmas stockings.

  • Gillman announced that leading receiver Alworth was "definitely out" of the championship game "unless there's a magic whirlpool. I haven't been able to find one yet." Lance had been hurt in Q1 of the previous week's game when he was blocked by Oakland LB Archie Mattos. Alworth suffered a hyper-extension of the left knee, which means it was bent in the direction in which knees aren't supposed to bend. How tough a blow is it? Sid asked rhetorically. You tell me. It's obvious. But we have some things left. Alworth added, I can hardly walk. I can only bend the knee half way.
  • He said that Jerry Robinson would take over at FL for Alworth. The former Grambling star had seen limited action during the season, catching 10 passes for 93y and no TDs. He was also used on the punt return and kickoff teams.
  • The Chargers coach also named Tobin Rote as his QB in what would be the 36-year-old's final game before retirement. John Hadl had started 8 of the 14 games under C but had thrown two INTs in the 21-20 loss to the Raiders.
    Hadl: The day before the championship game in Buffalo, Sid told me he was going to start ­ because of his experience in championship games. I went haywire. We had a big fight about it.
  • Saban had also created a QB controversy by starting 2nd-year pro Daryle Lamonica in the all-important final game against Boston. However, with the chips on the line, he would go with eight-year veteran Jack Kemp, who had started the first 13 games.
    A subplot of the big game was that Buffalo had claimed Kemp from San Diego in 1962 for the $100 waiver price. Jack still made his home in San Diego.

Alworth's injury, coupled with a threat of snow, established the weather-hardened Bills as strong favorites to bring their football-crazy city its first pro football champion­ship going back to the All-American Football Conference.

  • Standing room tickets were grabbed up and War Memorial Stadium was expect­ed to be bulging with 5,000 people above the normal capacity of 37,500.
  • Kickoff was set for 2 PM EST, with ABC televising nationally for the last time. Curt Gowdy would supply the play-by-play while Paul Christman would serve as color analyst.
  • It would be ABC's last telecast of an AFL game.
1964 San Diego Chargers
# Player Pos. Hgt. Wgt. College Exp.
18 Tobin Rote QB 6-3 211 Rice 15
19 Lance Alworth WR 6-0 185 Arkansas 3
20 Gerry McDougall FB 6-3 225 UCLA 3
21 John Hadl QB 6-1 215 Kansas 3
22 Keith Lincoln FB 6-1 215 Washington State 4
23 Paul Lowe HB 6-0 205 Oregon State 5
25 Dick Westmoreland DB 6-1 190 North Carolina A&T 2
29 Jerry Robinson E 5-11 190 Grambling State 3
30 Bob Horton LB 6-2 230 Boston University 1
33 Kenny Graham S 6-0 210 Washington State 1
38 Jacque MacKinnon E 6-4 235 Colgate 4
45 Speedy Duncan DB 5-10 180 Jackson State 1
47 Bud Whitehead S 6-0 185 Florida State 4
49 Jimmy Warren CB 5-11 175 Illinois 1
50 Chuck Allen LB 6-1 225 Washington 4
52 Don Rogers C 6-2 240 South Carolina 5
55 Frank Buncom MLB 6-2 235 USC 3
61 Ernie Park G 6-3 255 McMurry 2
64 Pat Shea G 6-1 250 USC 4
65 Sam Gruneisen C-G 6-1 240 Villanova 3
71 Fred Moore DT 6-3 255 Oklahoma, Mem. St. 1
72 Gary Kirner G-T 6-3 255 USC 1
74 Ron Mix T 6-4 250 USC 5
75 Ernie Wright T 6-4 270 Ohio State 5
76 Henry Schmidt DT 6-4 255 USC, Trinity (TX) 6
77 Ernie Ladd DT 6-9 290 Grambling State 4
78 Walt Sweeney G 6-4 255 Syracuse 2
79 George Gross DT 6-3 270 Auburn 2
82 Bob Mitinger LB 6-2 230 Penn State 3
83 Dave Kocourek TE 6-5 240 Wisconsin 5
85 Bob Petrich DE 6-4 250 West Texas A&M 2
86 Earl Faison DE 6-5 270 Indiana 4
88 Don Norton E 6-1 190 Iowa 5
89 Ron Carpenter LB 6-2 230 Texas A&M 1
1964 Buffalo Bills
# Player Pos. Hgt. Wgt. College Exp.
3 Pete Gogalak K 6-1 190 Cornell 1
12 Daryle Lamonica QB 6-3 215 Notre Dame 2
15 Jack Kemp QB 6-1 200 Occidental 8
20 Bobby Smith HB 6-0 205 North Texas 1
22 Charley Warner DB-HB 6-0 175 Prairie View 2
23 Eugene Sykes S 6-1 200 LSU 2
24 Booker Edgerson CB 5-10 185 Western Illinois 3
25 Oliver Dobbins DB 6-0 180 Morgan State 1
26 George Saimes S 5-11 185 Michigan State 2
30 Wray Carlton HB 6-2 225 Duke 5
34 Cookie Gilchrist FB 6-3 250 None 3
40 Ed Rutkowsi KR 6-1 200 Notre Dame 2
42 Butch Byrd CB 6-0 210 Boston University 1
45 Hagood Clarke DB 6-0 205 Florida 1
46 Ray Abruzzese DB 6-1 195 Alabama 3
47 Willie Ross FB 5-10 200 Nebraska 1
50 Al Bemiller G 6-3 245 Syracuse 4
51 John Tracey LB 6-3 225 Texas A&M 6
52 Walt Cudzik C 6-2 230 Purdue 11
55 Paul Maguire P 6-0 230 The Citadel 5
58 Mike Stratton LB 6-3 225 Tennessee 3
64 Harry Jacobs LB 6-1 225 Bradley 5
66 Billy Shaw G 6-2 260 Georgia Tech 4
67 Joe O'Donnell G-T 6-2 260 Michigan 1
70 Tom Sestak DT 6-5 265 Baylor, McNeese State 3
72 Ron McDole DE 6-4 265 Nebraska 4
73 George Flint G 6-4 240 Arizona State 3
75 Dudley Meredith DT 6-4 280 Florida, Lamar 2
77 Stew Barber T 6-2 250 Pnn State 4
78 Jim Dunaway DT 6-4 275 Mississippi 2
81 Bill Groman WR 6-0 194 Heidelberg 5
84 Ernie Warlick TE 6-3 235 North Carolina Central 3
85 Glenn Bass WR 6-2 200 East Carolina 4
88 Tom Day DE a6-2 250 North Carolina A&T 5

War Memorial Stadium


Joe Collier


Keith Lincoln bursts up middle on game's first play.


Lincoln catches a pass on San Diego's opening drive.


Lincoln blocks as Tobin Rote passes.


First quarter action


Kemp flees Bob Petrich.


Speedy Duncan roars upfield with the kickoff.


Ron Carpenter stalks Kemp.


Gilchrist rumbles in Q2.


Second quarter action


Jack Kemp calls signals.


Rote confers with Coach Gillman.


Ron McDole tackles Paul Lowe.


Butch Byrd


Stratton intercepts Rote's pass that he wanted to throw over Don Norton's head.



Late action


Dick Westmoreland


Keith Kinderman


Cookie and Jack exult.

The Californians couldn't help but be pleased with the game day weather.
  • The thermometer reached an unseasonable 47°.
  • However, the morning rain left the field damp and slippery in spots, especi­ally along the edges and in the end zones. Sand was spread on the worst spots.
    Buffalo's D-coordinator Joe Collier recalled: Sid Gillman was fit to be tied because our field was in terrible shape. That was the only practice field we had. We just wore it out. ... So the field was not very conducive to the Chargers, who were based on speed. Gillman threatened to call the game off. He called the commissioner. We had bigger guys on the defensive line in those days than most teams. ... And our linebackers were big. We played in the mud and the snow a lot, and big guys have a little bit of an advantage.
    Billy Shaw: Ernie [Ladd] and Kansas City's Buch Buchanan were the largest in the league at that time. Ernie was a mammoth presence. He was so big and strong, he didn't have to be mean. ... When the lineups were introduced before the championship game, ... I was on the sidelines. He came to the middle of the field and pointed at me. People said it set me on fire. I just know I was scared.
A record playoff crowd of 40,242 saw the complexion of the game change on one first quarter play.
  • Quarter 1
    The Chargers started like a house afire. Starting from the 20, FB Keith Lincoln burst up the middle 38y on a draw play as G Walt Sweeney and T Ernie Wright moved out DT Jim Dunaway to open a gaping hole. Then Lincoln got five at the middle. From the spread formation Gillman had put in for the game, Tobin Rote tossed to Lincoln on a button hook for 11 and on the next play pitched to TE Dave Kocourek, who had maneuvered in behind DB Charlie Warner. Then came a 26y pass from Rote to Kocourek, who grabbed the ball running down the right side of the EZ to climax the drive that took only 2:11. Chargers 7 Bills 0 (12:49)
    After a good kickoff return, Buffalo moved from its 40 to its 49 on runs by Wray Carlton and Cookie Gilchrist. But an incompletion brought in Paul Maguire, who punted to the 7.

    Jack Kemp sets up to pass.
    San Diego again started strong, striking quickly from the 7 to their 34. Then came the play that would forever be known as the "hit heard round the world." On a 2nd-and-10 situation with DT Tom Sestak in his face, Rote threw a swing pass in the left flat to Lincoln. The ball and All-Star LB Mike Stratton arrived simultaneously, the tackler smashing his shoulder into Keith's midsection. The FB who had averaged 13y per rush to that point, left the game after with the help of three Chargers. He would not return. Video of the hit ...
    Stratton in the locker room: I thought Lincoln had nothing more than the breath knocked out of him. I never realized I had broken a rib.
    Years later, Mike recounted the play. They always ran kind of a curl pattern to the wide receiver and would run a flare with the back. It seemed as if the QB would take his cue from the LB. If the LB was in the line of fire and far enough back, they would dump it off to the RB. They'd already run that once or twice, so I decided, "I'll try something new." When I saw the pattern develop, I just turned my back to the QB and took several steps to the WR, then stopped and turned back and went back toward the QB. If they caught me, the most they could do was throw to the WR. I started back for Lincoln, and I saw they were throwing to him. It was just, put your head down and try to dig the dirt because, golly, if Lincoln caught the ball in time to give me a juke, hell, he could have been gone.
    Lincoln recalled: We were pretty confident about how we had just scored. But we decided we were going to show Buffalo a new look on offense. We called it a delayred double-flare action to the left side. I went out of the backfield for a flare pass. Tobin had Lance run like a post. For a split second, Lance was open. He looked at me and looked at me, then looked at Lance again, then came to me. Well, the first time he looked at me, Stratton was about 20 yards downfield. He saw me out there, knew I was his man. So he started coming. In the meantime, Rote decided he was coming to me; the rush was in on him; he threw the Goddamn ball to me like you'd throw a snowball down a chimney. It seemed as though it would never get to me. And just as the ball got to me, Stratton hit me. It was a solid hit, a clean one, nothing dirty about it. When I went up for the ball, I exposed the sides of my chest and stomach area. That's where Stratton hit me. He separated my sternum, rib case.
    Stratton: You just kind of get up and go back to the huddle. I didn't have any idea what was happening. When we got back to the huddle, all of us looked over there. I think Harry Jacobs, the MLB, went ahead and called the defense that we were going to run for the next play. We were getting ready to break the huddle and Lincoln was still down.
    Joe Collier: I later told a writer from Sports Illustrated that a thrill went up and down the bench. When that was in the magazine, I got 10 or 15 letters from people saying I was a sadist: "How could you say that after he got hurt?"
"The hit heard round the world ..."

L: Mike Stratton belts Keith Lincoln. R: Ron Mix tries to help his fallen teammate.
Starting from their 36, the Bills moved into scoring position. Jack Kemp found Glenn Bass for 19y, then Ernie Warlick for 15 to put Buffalo in busi­ness with 1st-and-Goal from the 10.
Warlick had been a three-time All-Star in the Canadian Football League, where he had played with Kemp before joining the Bills in 1962.
Kemp was known for his toughness. The story goes that Gillman put him on waivers because Jack had fractured his finger on the helmet of a rush­ing lineman, and Sid believed Jack wouldn't recover from the injury. Jack took a football to a doctor and told him, I want you to set this finger on the profile of the football.
Wray Carlton carried twice to the 5 before a pass to Elbert Dubenion failed. So Pete Gogolak, "the side-saddle kicker," rammed through a 12 yarder. Chargers 7 Bills 3
In a twinkling, the Chargers almost made it 14-3. Leslie "Speedy" Duncan took the kickoff 6y deep in the EZ and raced upfield. Behind expert blocking, he rambled 71y to the Buffalo 35. The last men standing were Gogalak, who didn't even wear shoulder pads, and former Charger Paul Maguire, who just managed to pull him down. The run set a record for a kickoff return in an AFL championship game. However, the effort was wasted when, two plays later, Rote went against conventional football wisdom that says never throw crossfield when you're rushed. Warner picked off the pass and returned to the Bills 28.
Gilchrist rolled down the sideline for 31y. Then Kemp located Warlick for 27. The period ended with the Bills facing 4th down at the 8.
End of Q1: Chargers 7 Bills 3

George Gross (79) and Earl Faison (86) converge on Cookie Gilchrist.
  • Quarter 2
    The FG unit came out. But Daryle Lamonica, the holder, got up and tried to circle LE only to be brought down by big Earl Faison at the 5, a yard short of the 1st down.
    When asked after the game why he called for a fake FG, Saban said, I didn't call for it. Daryle spotted a weakness in San Diego's defense and felt he could roll out for a first down. He called the automatic and out, and two outside men missed the call.
    The visitors moved to the 21 before John Hadl punted to the Buffalo 45.
    This time, the Bills weren't to be denied. Kemp hit swift Elbert Dubenion for 18. Gilchrist and Carlton gained a 1st down at the 27. Dubenion picked up 8 on a reverse. Then, Kemp, about to be thrown for a big loss, flipped a 15y pass to Gilchrist to the 4. Carlton plowed through RT to pay dirt from there.
    Bills 10 Chargers 7 (7:49)

    Wray Carlton scores Buffalo's first TD.
    The home team scored again before halftime on Gogalak's second FG that was set up by Gilchrist's 39y run. Bills 13 Chargers 7 (2:28)
    San Diego looked like they would at least get a FG before the break when they drove into enemy territory. However, it was not to be. The Chargers received a break when Stratton picked off a pass, but interference was called on Butch Byrd against Don Norton to advance the ball 25y. With 40 seconds to go at the Buffalo 15, the Chargers rushed to the line of scrimmage. Intending to kill the clock, Rote took the snap and tried to throw the ball over the head of Norton near the sideline. Instead, the pigskin landed in the arms of LB Stratton.
    Rote: I made one awful mistake. I wanted to throw what we call a "clutch," when we run up to the line and I throw the ball out of bounds. I would have thrown that ball 40 yards up into the stands, but I got it too low. I didn't even see that guy.
    Gillman on the missed opportunity: If we get a field goal, it turns the game around. We might even have got a touchdown.
    Halftime score: Bills 13 Chargers 7

    Chargers gang up on Gilchrist.
The Bills continued to stifle the San Diego offense.
  • Quarter 3
    Early in the half, Chargers HB Paul Lowe was felled by a leg injury. He ultimately returned but at half speed and was never a factor in the bruising game.
    Jerry Robinson, Alworth's replacement who had yet to catch a pass, came close to putting his club back in front. He fielded a bouncing punt by Maguire on the SD 35, broke several tackles, and appeared to have an open lane down the sideline to the EZ. Instead, he cut back, and Maguire nailed him on the Buffalo 42. John Hadl had been warming up, and after two plays gained only a yard, Gillman sent him in. But Byrd picked off the rollout pass at the 18.
    Gillman explained his QB change afterward. We wanted a rollout, and Hadl is a pretty good rollout passer. Still, Rote expressed disappointment in being taken out. I just felt that at that stage, I knew more what to do.

    Gross and Ron Carpenter have their hands full trying to tackle Gilchrist.
    A steady drizzle started falling that lasted the rest of the game.
  • Quarter 4
    Playing keepaway with the lead, the Bills gave Gilchrist plenty of work. In be­tween, Kemp went to slant patterns to Bass, another former Charger. The maneuver worked like a charm when Glenn broke away for 51y before Dick Westmoreland tackled him at the 1. It took two tries, but Kemp pushed over. Bills 20 Chargers 7 (9:32)
    Duncan again electrified the SD sideline with a 49y kickoff return to the Buffalo 46. A great catch by Kocourek advanced the ball 26y. Lowe darted for 13. Then Lincoln's replacement, Keith Kinderman, gained 6 to the 7. But an offside penalty stalled the drive. Foresaking the FG, Hadl threw toward Robinson running open in the EZ, but the receiver slipped down. The Chargers were hit with a personal foul penalty after the play.
    Gillman: I thought we had a chance right up to then. He had made up his mind to go for an onside kick if they scored the TD.
    During the period, Gilchrist retired with a bruised rib. But he had done much more damage to the San Diego defense.
    Maguire put the icing on the cake with a gorgeous 64y punt to the SD 2.
    With 26 seconds left, Buffalo's impassioned fans broke through police restraining lines, took down both goalposts, and continued to run and circle the field while San Diego tried to get off its last play. Police had to push the crowd away from Hadl when the Charger QB was flattened and dazed on a running play in the game's closing moment.
    Part of the mob surrounded their captive QB, Kemp, and carried him around the field until the gendarmes liberated him so he can join his teammates in the locker room.
    FINAL SCORE: BILLS 20 CHARGERS 7

    Young Ron Jaworski, who would have a 15-year NFL career at QB and become an ESPN commentator, came out of his seat in the end zone and ran onto the field to celebrate the championship of his beloved Bills. Decades later, he recalled: I remember seeing Jack Kemp being carried off on the shoulders of his teammates. I shook hands with a few of the players, and center Al Bemiller gave me his chin strap. I felt like I was almost part of that Bills team; it was one of the happiest moments of my llife. But I was also just a few feet away from a disconsolate Sid Gillman, miserable from the cold and obviously despondent over his team's 20-7 defeat. He brushed past me for a fleeting moment, and then he was gone. I was only thirteen at the time and certainly didn't feel sorry for him - I was exhilarated about my team winning a title. But I will never forget the heartsick expression on Sid's face.
    Little did Ron know that Gillman would one day be his offensive coordinator with an Eagles team that went to the Super Bowl.
The Bills enjoyed a large rushing advantage.

Final statistics:

  • First downs: Bills 21 Chargers 15
  • Rushing: Bills 41-219 Chargers 18-124
  • Passing: Bills 20-10-0/167 Chargers 36-13-3/135
  • Return yardage: Bills 7-64 Chargers 6-233
  • Fumbles-Lost: Bills 0-0 Chargers 1-0
  • Penalties: Bills 3-45 Chargers 3-20
  • Punting average: Bills 5-46.8 Chargers 5-36.4

The gross receipts were lower than expected because ABC paid only $60,000 for the TV rights. According to the league, the low figure may have been to a large extent because of the end of the line for ABC with the AFL.

Postgame

Buffalo Locker Room

  • Owner Ralph Wilson called the championship "the culmination of a long-awaited desire." I'm so happy, I don't really know what to say. They're two great football teams. And I guess the thing to say is that the better team won. But believe me, I won't take anything away from San Diego. They played their hearts out.
  • Saban was actually happy that the Chargers scored first. It jarred us quick. It jarred us to our senses. It woke us up. He admitted, though, that the early TD scared him. I thought immedi­ately - could it be another 51-10 rout? He was referring to San Diego's beatdown of Boston in the 1963 title clash.
  • Stratton had no doubt his jarring hit on Lincoln hurt the Chargers. It definitely hurt San Diego.
    Stratton had been one of 34 players taken by the Bills in the 1962 draft. He almost didn't make the team and didn't start out as a LB. As he recalled: Saban ... had become the head coach ..., and I wanted to be a tight end. Lou had called out all the names of the players we had in camp and what time we supposed to go out (onto the field), and he never did call my name. So afterward, I walked over to him and said, "Coach, what group would you like me to go out with?" He looked at me and says, "What was your name again?" I told him, and he said, "Ah, just go out there with someone! Anyway, they had already got Ernie Warlick from the Canadian League, and he was pretty well set as their tight end, so I didn't get much of an opportunity. They started me at defensive end, and I tried to play a little bit there. And then we got a bunch of linebackers hurt, thanks goodness, and they changed me to linebacker. It was just a series of very fortunate events. ... Most linebackers, I think, came to linebacker from tight end. We sort of all pictured ourselves as tight ends, although not very many other people did.
  • Kemp: This is even better than last week. These were the two greatest weeks of my life. We con­trolled it today as we did last week against Boston, and that did it. The wet field never bothered me. With that big one protecting me - Cookie and Carlton too - I had no worries.
  • Gilchrist, who wanted to be traded before the season, was asked if he would retire. I can't make a statement on that. But I'd be happy to come back on the right terms.

  • Lou Saban, Pete Gogalak, Jack Kemp, and Wray Carlton rejoice.
San Diego Locker Room
  • Gillman told his team before the press came in: You've had a good year. Forget about it. You gave it a real try. You did a good job.
  • By the time reporters were allowed in, he was puffing on a pipe philosophically. They just beat us. Buffalo is a fine football team with great balance, great running, great throwing. The Bills are truly great champions. He refused to fix the defeat on the loss of Alworth and Lincoln. Injuries are part of football. Still, he clearly missed two of his offensive stars. If there was a turning point, that pass interception was it. The loss of Keith Lincoln also hurt us. I would say, if anything, his loss helped Buffalo a great deal. We lost a lot of our football team when Lincoln was injured. We've got to have Lincoln, and we've got to have good throwing. But our kids have done well. They have won the Western Division championship four out of five years. They are to be congratu­lated.
  • Rote: We just didn't score. Our defense played good, but we just didn't score. ... If I hadn't under­thrown that pass in the second quarter, we might have gotten some kind of score and turned the game in a different direction.
  • Ernie Ladd helped Lincoln, in much distress, get out of his uniform. Later, Ernie Wright had to knot Keith's necktie for him.
  • Hadl said of his last play flattening: I just got knocked out. I can't remember anything.
  • Alworth: It's been a long season - and all for nothing. They won the championship, and they beat us three times this season, but I'm still not convinced they have the best team. I'd like to play them when all our people are well.
    Ron Mix in 2003: The Bills are still fond of saying that they won because Mike Stratton broke Keith Lincoln's ribs. But as valuable as Keith was, he wasn't our whole team. We played many games without him. We played a lot of games without a lot of our stars and kept winning. The Bills were just a good team, period. They probably would have beaten us whether they knocked Keith out of the game or not.
1964 AFL Champion Buffalo Bills

References: War Stories from the Field, Joseph Hession & Kevin Lynch (1994)
Going Long: The Wild 10-Year Saga of the Renegade American Football League
in the Words of Those Who Lived It:
Jeff Miller (2003)
Then Levy Said to Kelly...: The Best Buffalo Bills Stories Ever Told, Jim Gehman (2008)
The Little League That Could: A History of the American Football League, Ken Rappoport (2010)
The Games That Changed the Game: The Evolution of the NFL in Seven Sundays,
Ron Jaworski with Greg Cosell and David Plaut (2010)
Top of Page