Golden Baseball Magazine
Baseball's Memorable Games
The articles in this series focus on interesting games from baseball's rich history.
A game may be interesting because of its importance (for example, World Series Game 7s
or the last game of a pennant race), because of the individual achievements involved
(for example, a no-hitter or a four-homer game), or because of the wacky events that
occurred during the contest.
Notepad


Mordecai Brown


Doc Crandall


Al Bridwell


Dave Davenport

June 16, 1914 - Historic Extra-Inning Comeback
My father celebrated his 10th birthday on this date, probably with his family in Arkansas, while one state north an exciting baseball game took place in St. Louis.
  • The Mound City hosted three professional baseball teams that year - the Cardinals of the National League, the Browns of the American, and the Terriers of the new Federal League.
  • The "outlaw league," as "Organized Baseball" called it, allowed players to avoid the restrictions of the reserve clause of MLB.
  • The Federal League fielded teams in eight cities, six of whom also had American or National League teams or both.
    • Baltimore Terrapins
    • Brooklyn Tip-Tops
    • Buffalo Blues
    • Chicago Whales
    • Indianapolis Hoosiers
    • Kansas City Packers
    • Pittsburgh Rebels
    • St. Louis Terriers

The three St. Louis clubs played at three different venues.

  • Cardinals - Robison Field
  • Browns - Sportsman's Park
  • Terriers - Handlan Park
 
Handlan Park, St. Louis

The Terriers were managed by Mordecai "Three-Finger" Brown, who had been a star pitcher for the Chicago Cubs. Other players on the Terriers who had one or more seasons of major league experience were:

  • C Mike Simons - Pirates 1909-1913
  • P-IF Doc Crandall - Giants 1908-1913
  • SS Al Bridwell - Reds 1905, Braves 1906-07 and 1911-12, Giants 1908-11, Cubs 1913
  • OF Delos Drake - Tigers 1911
  • OF Ward Miller - Pirates 1909, Reds 1910, Cubs 1912-13
  • OF Fred Kommers - Pirates 1913
  • P Bob Groom - Senators 1909-1913
  • P Ed Willett - Tigers 1908-1912

The June 16 opponent was the Brooklyn Tip-Tops, who boasted these former big leaguers.

  • 1B Art Griggs - Browns 1909-10, Indians 1911-12
  • OF Danny Murphy - Athletics 1903-13
  • 2B Solly Hofman - Cubs 1907-11
  • C Grover Land - Indians 1910-11
  • P Tom Seaton - Phillies 1912-13
  • P Ed Lafitte - Tigers 1911
  • P Byron Houck - Phillies 1912-13
Starting Lineups
Brooklyn Tip-Tops
George Anderson LF .222
Claude Cooper CF .185
Art Griggs 1B .167
Danny Murphy RF .320
Solly Hofman 2B .207
Tex Wisterzil 3B .258
Ed Gagnier SS .226
Grover Land C .286
Tom Seaton P 10-4
St. Louis Terriers
Armando Marsans 2B .286
Jack Tobin RF .293
Ward Miller LF .345
Fred Kommers CF .298
Delos Drake 1B .239
Al Boucher 3B .251
Al Bridwell SS .213
Mike Simon C .301
Dave Davenport P 0-0


Danny Murphy


Tom Seaton


Armando Marsans


Hugh Miller

The author of the Brooklyn Eagle's article on the game started this way:

Globe trotters tell us that baseball is played in practically every civilized country on this mundane sphere, but one would have to travel to Mars to witness such a game ...

A "crowd" estimated at 300, perhaps held down by the Flag Day celebration in St. Louis, saw the game get off to a fast start.

  • The Tip-Tops struck for 3 in the first against Dave Davenport. George Anderson singled, Claude Cooper walked, Art Griggs bunted them over, then Danny Murphy whacked a homer.
    Davenport was making his first start for the Terriers after jumping from the Reds, for whom he went 2-2.
  • Facing Tom Seaton, who won 27 games for the Phillies in 1913, the home team matched that number in the bottom of the inning on five hits and an error.
    Seaton's switch to the Federal League was influenced by a tragic family event that occurred August 7, 1913. As he pitched against the Cubs in Chicago, his wife Rene was in labor and in danger of her losing her life. After he pitched seven innings, losing 5-2, he hurried to Philadelphia where his child had already died. Doctors gave Rene no hope, but she survived. However, she harbored a grudge against the Phillies and manager Red Dooin. She claimed that Dooin had withheld from her husband a telegram sent before the game urging him to rush to Philadelphia.
    On February 18, 1914, Seaton signed a three-year contract to play for the Tip-Tops at $7,000 per year. But he reported to spring training in Shreveport LA with the Chicago Federals! After some haggling, the righthander agreed to play for Brooklyn after they increased his salary to $8,500 per year.

The game stayed 3-3 until the 8th.

  • A single by Griggs, Murphy's sacrifice, Solly Hofman's double, and Ted Wisterzil's triple plated two.
  • But the Terriers rallied against Seaton for two in the bottom of the 9th on three hits and a walk to send the game into extra ininngs.

The three-fingered skipper took over for Davenport in the 10th and set down the visitors in the first two extra frames. Seaton did the same to the Terriers. But Brown fell apart in the 12th.

  • The inning started innocently enough when Cooper struck out.
  • But Griggs tripled, Murphy and Hofman singled, and Westerzil doubled to make it 8-5.
  • Eddie Gagnier singled. Despite the lead, Grover Land sacrificed.
  • P Seaton homered. 11-5
  • But the Tip-Tops weren't through. Anderson singled and Cooper doubled to make it 12-5.
  • Griggs, like Cooper batting for the second time in the inning, simply waved at three pitches to get the inning over. File that under "Don't count your chickens before they hatch."
  • After all, as the Brooklyn correspondent wrote, "seven nice, juicy runs" are "apparently enough to win any game."

But not so fast, my friend.

  • Fans started to file out but heistated when Tobin lofted one of Seaton's deliveries over the RF wall. 12-6
  • Ward Miller popped to Griggs, and the customers started out again.
  • Then the tornado broke. Seaton would not record another out.
  • Fred Kommers, Delos Drake, and Al Boucher each singled. 12-7
  • LF Anderson dropped Al Bridwell's fly, and Mike Simon walked. 12-8
  • Grover Hartley pinch-hit for his manager and beat out an infield hit. 12-9
  • Armando Marsans's single made it 12-11 and finally ended the day for Seaton.
  • Manager Bill Bradley brought in Byron Houck, but he yielded a single to Jack Tobin to load the bases. Then he walked Miller to force in the tying run. The St. Louis fans celebrated by throwing bats, hats, and coats
  • Bradley turned to Rudy Summers to hold the line but to no avail. Hugh Miller batted for Kommers and rapped a game-winning single. The Tip-Tops couldn't even get two outs.
  • Seven runs in the top of the 12th followed by eight in the bottom of the inning!
    Terriers 13 Tip-Tops 12
Research conducted by the Elias sports Bureau has determined that, since 1901, the largest extra-inning deficit an American or National League squad has ever overcome is five.
References: Baseball Records Registry: The Best and Worst Single-Day Performances & the Stories Behind Them,
Joseph J. Dittmar (1997)
"A Tip-Top Takedown," Joe Hoppel, Cardinals Gameday Magazine, 2015 Issue 2