xxx
Clash of Titans
Games featuring a future Hall of Fame coach on each sideline.
December 3, 1949: Notre Dame @ Southern Methodist
Frank Leahy vs Madison Bell
"Greatest I Ever Coached"
Going into the last game of the 1949 season, Frank Leahy's Notre Dame Fighting Irish had not lost a game in almost four full seasons. The 1945 squad, coached by Hugh Devore while Leahy served in the military, lost its final game 39-7 at the Great Lakes Naval Air Station. Then Leahy returned to post the following records.
  • 1946: 8-0-1 with the famous 0-0 tie with Army in Yankee Stadium
  • 1947: 9-0
  • 1948: 9-0-1, the tie being with Southern California 14-14 in Los Angeles
  • 1949: 9-0 including a 32-0 shellacking of USC in South Bend the week before the SMU finale
Understandably, the Irish were solid favorites heading to Dallas—as many as 28 points in some betting lines. The Mustangs sported a 5-3-1 record and were coming off back-to-back losses to Baylor (35-26) and archrival Texas Christian (21-13). Adding to coach Madison Bell's prob­lems was the fact that a leg injury would sideline star TB Doak Walker in Bell's last game before retirement.
Walker's replacement, Kyle Rote, played the game of his life and nearly led the Mustangs to the upset of the season before an overflow crowd of 75,457. Rote "smashed and crashed" for 115y on the ground and completed 10 of 24 passes for 146y. Notre Dame's 19-year-old QB Bob Williams, who succeeded Heisman Trophy winner Johnny Lujack, connected on 11 of 18 for 165 yards, inclu­ding two touchdowns.
Back-to-Back TDs
The Mustangs took the opening kickoff and, led by Rote who took the direct snap from center in place of Walker, drove into Irish territory. Kyle completed three passes in a row from what today is called the "Shotgun" formation. But after a 15y holding penalty, sophomore QB Fred Benners threw into the hands of ND's Jerry Groom, who returned the interception to the SMU 31.
Penalties and incompletions throttled each team's next advances. Finally, after nine scoreless minutes, Notre Dame broke through when Williams sailed a 42y touchdown pass to Bill Wight­kin on the dead run behind Rote. Notre Dame 7 SMU 0.
The most sensational play of the game came a few minutes later. Rote handed to Johnny Champion who lofted a pass to Zohn Milam who caught the ball on the ND 40 and ran to the 6, where DB John Petibon overtook him. That was a crucial play because the Irish held on downs at the one foot line.

L: Kyle Rote (Southern Methodist University Rotunda Yearbook Class of 1950)
R: Bob Lolly and Jim Mutscheller stop Rote on one foot line
.
(University of Notre Dame Dome Yearbook Class of 1950)
Irish Extend Their Lead
Following an Irish interception shortly before the half, Williams' pass was deflected into the hands of Ernie Zajeski for a touchdown. A missed PAT left the visitors ahead 13-0 at the break.
An offside penalty negated a Notre Dame touchdown pass from Williams to mammoth E Leon Hart shortly before the end of the half.
The Irish were on their way to another touchdown in the third quarter when Ernie Zalejski fumbled, and Jack Halliday recovered for SMU at the Pony 13.
SMU started moving the ball in the third quarter after recovering another Zalejski fumble, this one at the ND 47. Rote drove his team to the 3, where he powered into the end zone. Bill Sulli­van's extra point made it 13-7.
Later in the period, E Jim Mutscheller intercepted Rote at the SMU 22. Williams passed to Hart, who lateraled to Frank Spaniel for a first down on the 12. With Hart playing fullback, three runs moved the ball to the 3. Bill Barrett took the ball into the end zone from there to stretch the lead back to 13. Notre Dame 20 SMU 7

L: John Champion (Southern Methodist University Rotunda Yearbook Class of 1951)
R: Rote scores first SMU TD. (Southern Methodist University Rotunda Yearbook Class of 1950)
The final 15 minutes saw what the AP writer called "the gutsiest performance by a foot­ball player in the history of the game." Bell inserted H. N. "Rusty" Russell at quarter­back, allow­ing Rote to move to halfback. Russell handed to Rote who, with the Irish keying on him, flipped the ball to Champion who caught it at the SMU 34 and raced to the Irish 1. Rote scored on the next play to bring the Mustangs back to a 6-point deficit. Notre Dame 20 SMU 14

L: Rusty Russell (Southern Methodist University Rotunda Yearbook Class of 1951)
R: Rote scores again. (Southern Methodist University Rotunda Yearbook Class of 1950)
SMU Ties Score
When the Irish were forced to punt on their next series, Billy Richards returned it to the ND 14. It took Rote only two plays to find the end zone for the third time. However, the extra point was blocked, leaving SMU tied with the #1 team in the land. Notre Dame 20 SMU 20
Irish Retake Lead And Barely Hold On
Trying to blunt the home team's momentum, Leahy again moved giant Leon Hart from end to fullback. The 260-pounder along with HB Emil Sitko battered the defense for 51 yards to set up Barrett's six-yard left end sweep for the go ahead score – 27-20 Irish.

L: Bill Barrett scores winning touchdown for Notre Dame as Dick Davis tackles too late.
R: Fred Benners (Southern Methodist University Rotunda Yearbook Class of 1950)
Rote led a last desperate drive to the 28. Then he had to leave the game after a hit by Hart. Sophomore Fred Benners replaced him and passed to H. N. Russell to the 5. Ben­ners was then put out of the game by Hart. Rote returned and ran to the 5. With less than four minutes left, facing fourth-and-goal, Rote's jump pass over the line to John Champion in the end zone was intercepted.
Barrett, Sitko, and Hart alternated carrying the ball to run out the clock to preserve the Notre Dame streak. The victory was their tightest of the season, the previous closest game having been 34-21 vs Michigan State.
Postgame
Labeled "Dr. Pessimism" by one writer, Leahy predicted before the 1949 season that his Notre Dame team would lose seven games. But immediately after the Dallas game, Leahy pronounced his '49 squad the "greatest I ever coached. It's got guts, it's got character."
Coach Matty Bell called his team's performance "the greatest effort I ever had a bunch of boys to give. It was the only one in which I served as coach and came out on the short end of the score that most people thought we won."
Rote gave the performance of his life. He ran for 115y, completed 10 of 24 passes for 146y, punted for a 48y average, and scored three touchdowns. It's no wonder Texas sportswriters voted his the best performance by a Texas athlete in the first half of the 20th century,
The first outsiders to enter the Notre Dame dressing room were Coach Matty Bell and his injured star, Doak Walker. Doak said that while he regretted his inability to play, he got satisfaction watching Notre Dame operate. The Fighting Irish squad gave the two visitors a rousing cheer as they left.
SMU's valiant effort caught the nation's attention. A nine-minute newsreel entitled "Football's Mighty Mustangs" played in theaters around the country in 1950. Coach Bell noted: "It was the greatest effort I ever had a bunch of boys give." Texas sports writers voted Rote's performance that day as the best by a Texas athlete in the first half of the 20th century
References:
Mustang Mania: SMU Football, Temple Pouncey (1981)
Many Autumns Ago: The
Frank Leahy Era at Boston College and Notre Dame, ed. Mike Bynum (1988)